Fairy Cakes Cupcakery


Our luscious 9 inch and 8 inch pies and tarts are available seasonally by special order, and can be found by the slice in the shop in the Fall, on Pie Day, during Southern Weekend, and when the whim strikes us. All pies are made from scratch from crust to filling to topping. Check Facebook or call for availability.

  • Traditional Apple with Leaf Cutout Crust- 6 pounds of apples, spices, and a show stopping crust of layered leaf cutouts
  • Double Crusted Pumpkin- a gingersnap pecan crust inside a traditional crust, fluffy pumpkin filling and a pecan streusel topping
  • Pecan- traditional, gooey, pecan filling
  • Derby- a gooey pecan pie with chocolate and bourbon
  • Sweet Potato Praline- fluffy sweet potato filling with a pecan praline topping
  • Coconut Cream- a toasted coconut crust filled with silky coconut custard and topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut
  • Kitchen Sink- a peanut-y graham cracker crust with fluffy peanut butter filling that’s loaded with Oreos, Peanut Butter Cups, Mini Chocolate Chips, Heath, and Butterfinger
  • Mississippi Mud- a brownie crust topped with marshmallows, toasted pecans, three different types of chocolate chips, and drizzled with marshmallow and salted caramel
  • Maple Walnut- a gooey filling similar to traditional pecan pie
  • Blueberry- three pounds of blueberries tossed with just a hint of lemon and topped with a lattice crust
  • Tart Cherry- three pounds of tart cherries, a hint of almond, and a lattice crust
  • Blueberries and Cream- blueberries in a sour cream custard with a streusel topping
  • Tollhouse- a traditional pie crust with a gooey chocolate chip cookie filling
  • Chocolate Ganache Tart- a chocolate cookie crust filled with creamy, rich dark chocolate ganache
  • Mile High Car Bomb- a chocolate cookie crust filled with rich whiskey ganache, fluffy chocolate stout mousse, and Baileys whipped cream
  • Mile High Chocolate Peppermint Pie- a chocolate cookie crust filled with dark chocolate peppermint ganache, chocolate peppermint mousse, and peppermint whipped cream

Traditional Apple Pie